I’m glad I waited a couple of days before posting my thoughts, because a lot of my opinions going into the draft (see the Oden/Durant saga) have changed because of what has occurred over the weekend.
My analysis will be a bit different than most, since I won’t pretend to know about every player drafted and make bold predictions about them based on someone else’s highlight package or three sentence profile.
Your GM did his job:
These are just the teams who did most of what they were supposed to, as in addressing a specific need or improving a strength without being dumb about it.
Chicago
Although I’m not crazy about Noah, I’m impressed that they nabbed Aaron Gray where they did.
Atlanta
Though about six years late, the Hawks finally have their point guard. I hope he succeeds just for Dominique’s sake. Horford would look even better on the Hawks if it weren’t for the fact that 1) Josh Smith is better at the PF than the SF, 2) they hadn’t wasted last year’s pick on Shelden Williams.
New York
I’m just assuming that the draft pick will be a steal, because it’s Isaiah. I’ve never heard of the guy, either. Jared Jeffries should start trying out for the Liberty.
The Randolph trade depends entirely on Isaiah continuing to work well with his players, because you really shouldn’t have Zach and Eddy Curry on the floor together for any defensive possessions. Having those two out there together would be like having Barry Word and Christian Okoye in the backfield at the same time. You’re not fooling anyone! We know you’re going to dump it inside and not pass out! If he can get them 28 minutes each and keep David Lee out of foul trouble playing beside them, then the trade was a good idea. Plus, they got rid of Francis.
Utah
Never seen Almond play, but Sloan isn’t into teaching and Wisconsin players aren’t dumb. Getting a big senior to put next to Deron will just add to the physical beatdown the Jazz put on every one they play. They should still try and trade AK for Richard Jefferson.
Miami
Daequan Cook actually reminds me a lot of Dwyane Wade, except with a jumpshot. I like combo-guard backcourts and this one should be good pretty quick. Dorell Wright just needs to wake up so the three of them can get the Heat some wins.
Washington
They still need help up front, but as I said above, I like combo-guard backcourts and this guy will definitely be better than DeShawn Stevenson.
Memphis
I wasn’t sold on Kyle Lowry, either.
We had to correct for last year’s screwup:
New Orleans realised that Peja sucks, so drafting another SF makes sense, 64 million later. Brewer should make the Marko Jaric and Trenton Hassell contracts look even worse. Charlotte had to decide whether drafting Sean May was a mistake by keeping Brandan Wright or if drafting Adam Morrison was a mistake by trading for J-Rich. Of course, they pick the more expensive option, although I like the 1-2-3 combination of Felton-Gerald Wallace and Richardson.
My GM is an idiot:
Sacramento, realising that Brad Miller is too slow to keep up with Kevin Martin, Quincy Douby and Francisco Garcia, drafts a slow big man who can’t defend.
Boston, in my Oden/Durant discussion, I stated that “It’s really too bad for Ainge, who drafts quite well but trades quite horribly.” Well, when Paul said he wanted a vet so they could contend, he probably should have said he wants to contend for more than an 8th seed.
Why would Milwaukee go after Yi with Brewer on the board and Charlie V on their team?
Phoenix is so concerned with saving money that they forgot that you make more money by actually getting to the Finals. Splitter was the difference between Nash getting broken down for a game-winning layup and that layup getting sent into the 4th row.
I either don’t know enough about your selection, or there’s nothing to say about your picks:
Philly, Dallas, Houston, Cleveland, Indy, Denver, the Clippers and the Magic
Anything else?
Although I initially hated the deal, Jason Kapono is going to make TJ Ford look like Isaiah Thomas and Chris Bosh look like David Robinson. With Jason and Anthony Parker licking threes from the corners, it’s going to be a layup drill for anyone on the Raptors who can dribble.
The reasoning behind the NBA age limit – Part 1 of 3
June 25, 2007 by champ
When people think about the rule passed by David Stern and the NBA, restricting players under 19 years of age on the day of the annual league entry draft, quality of the game, education, racism, human rights and are the usual bases for their feelings on the topic.
I will address (expose) these four sticking points, following with the real reason why this rule exists: money. Finally, I will propose a situation that would be much more beneficial for the league, general managers and players alike. Now, these thoughts have been stewing for a while, so don’t be mad if I subconsciously plagiarize.
First though, this article provides a summary of all of the American players to enter the NBA draft directly out of high school, without having played NCAA ball or professionally elsewhere (See: Jackson, Stephen). This covers everyone from Moses Malone in 1974 to Amir Johnson, the physical freak awaiting his chance to play for the Pistons.
Interestingly, this article suggests that high schoolers are just as, if not more, successful than the average NBA draftee, with nearly all making rotational contributions for their teams.
Quality of the Game
This is probably the most popular argument for supporters of the limit. They argue that unseasoned 18 year-old players, who take a number of years to develop, drop the quality of the game as the roster spot that that player fills could be better assumed by an older player who can contribute right away. Waiting for these youngster to improve guarantees extended stretches in games where a young player plays poorly as he attempts to gain the experience to eventually succeed. Kobe Bryant’s air balls against Utah in the playoffs are a pretty good example of this.
The problem with this argument is that NBA teams should never be in a position where there immediate AND long-term future depends entirely on the play of an 18 year old. What should happen is that, the bad teams draft immediate help (Dwyane Wade), which is what they need right now, while the good teams pick up players who they can stash away for a couple of years (Jermaine O’Neal). To me, it seems like there is a bigger issue with the inability of general managers to assess talent.
Part two coming soon…
Posted in Social Commentary, Sports | Leave a Comment »